Want to book an appointment with us?

Electric Toothbrush vs Manual: Busting the Myths

electric toothbrush vs manual

Brushing your teeth well makes the foundation of sound oral health. The American Dental Association (ADA) considers both manual and electric toothbrushes as effective at eliminating oral plaque, which causes disease and decay. If we carry out a comparison of electric toothbrush vs manual, each of the two categories of toothbrushes comes with its own advantages and disadvantages. Any toothbrush – manual or electric – which is proven effective and safe, is given a Seal of Acceptance by ADA.

However, when it comes to using electric toothbrushes, there are several myths and misconceptions. Here we have busted some of these myths and illustrated the corresponding facts.

Electric Toothbrush vs Manual – Myths Busted, Facts Explained

1. Myth: Electric toothbrushes cannot remove more plaque than manual toothbrushes.

Fact: The manufacturers of electric toothbrushes do make several bold claims about an electric toothbrush’s effectiveness in plaque removal. There have been claims of up to 100% more effective removal of plaque.

To make claims like these, the manufacturers are required to complete research and studies; however, these studies are quite often influenced and funded by the brands.

The clinical studies don’t have enough indication that there is such a noteworthy difference between both the categories of brushes.

However, an independent firm named Cochrane analyzed about 56 studies with more than 5000 participants. The investigations from these studies indicated that using an electric toothbrush compared to manual one led to an 11% decrease in plaque for 1 to 3 months of use, and a 21% plaque reduction on assessing after 3 months of use.

So, although the increase in the removal of plaque is not as significant as suggested by the major brands, this review does suggest that using an electric toothbrush comes with considerable benefits.

2. Myth: An electric toothbrush wears away or damages the teeth enamel and gums.

Fact: Well, the truth is quite the opposite!

In a clinical study conducted by Annette Weigand in 2012, a comparison of an electric toothbrush vs manual was carried out. It was found that manual toothbrushes were more abrasive to gums and teeth.

A study by Professor Addy also confirmed the absence of any evidence that suggested an electric toothbrush to be any worse for the gums and teeth.

However, there is a possibility for an electric brush to contribute to gum recession and tooth damage but only in those cases where the toothbrush is used in the wrong way. An incorrect technique is applied to teeth in such cases, and too much pressure is used.

3. Myth: Electric toothbrushes are designed to be used by specific people, unlike manual brushes.

Fact: There’s a belief that electric brushes were designed for those having specific needs – like those with restricted movement in the wrist or hand or those with medical conditions or disabilities limiting their ability to clean their teeth properly.

While electric brushes offer an advantage, without doubt, to those with disabilities or restricted movement that interfere with their ability to clean teeth properly, electric toothbrushes, however, were not designed for this purpose specifically. In fact, electric brushes are meant to be used by anyone.

As a matter of fact, electric brushes aim to make brushing teeth more enjoyable and convenient so that users brush teeth for the right time duration, instead of brushing for less time.

4. Myth: I need the most expensive toothbrush to get the best results with an electric toothbrush.

Fact: This is not true.

You can get most of the key benefits of an electric brush even by buying the cheapest model. Getting a slightly more premium model, nevertheless, comes with some advantages as they offer extra benefits and features.

You can buy a good electric toothbrush typically for $25-50, which has all the features you want or need. However, for just £15, you can get an electric toothbrush, which will be advantageous over a conventional toothbrush.

5. Myth: Electric toothbrush users will switch to manual toothbrushes again once the novelty wears off.

Fact: It’s possible that there’s some novelty to using an electric toothbrush for some and some users may switch to a manual toothbrush again. However, a few resorts back to a manual toothbrush in reality.

This is because when users begin using an electric toothbrush, they already invest in it financially and might not like going back to a manual toothbrush when they have paid for a toothbrush.

Convenience is often one of the reasons for sticking with an electric toothbrush. Whether it’s an electric or manual toothbrush, the time of brushing is 2 minutes. An electric toothbrush helps us maintain this time of brushing and makes brushing simpler. The brushing is also more efficient than a conventional toothbrush.

The biggest reason behind users sticking to electric brushes is the cleanliness they offer. When it comes to electric toothbrush vs manual, an electric brush is better for most users than a manual brush. The significant differences convince users to continue using electric brushes, rather than switch back to manual toothbrushes.

Watch this Video!

We’ve made a video to help you further understand the key differences between electric and manual toothbrushes.

Wrap Up

Considering the benefits of an electric toothbrush, if you are questioning – Are electric toothbrushes better than manual ones – and whether you should switch to an electric toothbrush, our dental office in Iowa can help you make the right choice! Book an appointment and consult one of our dentists. Our dentist can answer any questions you might have about electric toothbrushes and help you choose the right toothbrush!

Request An Appointment Online

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.